NAB wants Satellite Radio recall

Wednesday, February 14, 2007 at 6:57 AM

Wah wah wah!The NAB has renewed their plea to the FCC to issue a complete recall of "unlawful" satellite radio receivers.

Last year the NAB whistled the same tune in a similar letter to the FCC, and later a letter to both Sirius and XM. Apparently causing XM and Sirius a massive disruption in production isn't enough for NAB president David Rehr. No, now we need an all out recall of all satellite radios that are "interfering" with FM.

In his letter, Rehr is particularly concerned with listeners of public and religious programming being subjected to explicit and "unwelcome" programming - particularly "The Howard Stern Show." And as expected, Rehr referred to a recent New York Times article to back up his claims that this is going on.

It's obvious that the NAB is quite pleased with themselves with what they were able to pull off last year, and they're not going to stop pressuring the FCC for more drastic measures. Afterall, who needs to compete in the marketplace when you can just use political pressure to get the job done for you?

[View Letter (PDF) via MediaWeek

(For you lazy clickers, you can read full text of Rehr's letter after the jump...) 


Dear Mr. Chairman:

Recent media reports demonstrate that unlawful interference caused by satellite radio devices to free over-the-air radio service remains a pervasive problem. Therefore, the National Association of Broadcasters (NAB) renews its plea for the Commission to pursue a recall of satellite radio devices present in the marketplace that do not comply with Part 15 of the Commission’s rules.

As revealed in studies submitted to the Commission last summer by NAB and National Public Radio, interference from satellite radio reception devices often causes “bleed through” on FM frequencies. As a result, nonsubscribers listening to FM radio will receive satellite radio programming over FM frequencies, particularly FM listeners in their cars and listeners of public and religious programming on noncommercial stations typically located at the lower end of the FM band.

In response to numerous consumer complaints, Sirius and XM temporarily suspended production of their noncompliant devices in July 2006.2 Subsequently, the Commission certified newly designed devices, allowing Sirius and XM to resume the sale of Part 15-compliant radio devices.

However, as noted in the attached recent article from The New York Times, these actions did nothing to resolve interference caused by noncompliant satellite radio receivers already in consumers’ hands or on retailers’ shelves before Sirius and XM redesigned the faulty devices. NAB highlighted this problem in a letter to Sirius and XM, dated September 21, 2006, in which the association also sought the voluntary withdrawal of all noncompliant devices from the market, to no avail. Consequently, satellite radio continues to disrupt FM radio service, as consumers interested in noncommercial radio programming continue to receive unwelcome content such as The Howard Stern Show.

Given Sirius and XM’s recalcitrance, it is left to the Commission to take corrective action. Therefore, NAB repeats its request that the Commission seek a recall of noncompliant satellite radio devices to prevent further disruption of listeners’ access to free over-the-air radio.

NAB looks forward to discussing these and other issues of concern with you and your fellow Commissioners. Please let us know what we can do to assist the FCC in its consideration of these or other matters.

Best wishes.

David K. Rehr



It was a loss when the F.M. mod were removed from newer satellite radios, and now they are trying a recall of the older radios. I can't see a recall happening but we should be concerned and angry that they are even attempting to try this. Just leave satellite radio alone.

Time to turn back on my FM Modulator... the sound is not as good but danm.. if they are going to try to take it away from me I am going to transmit as much as I can!

It definitely was a hit to satrad last year. The new FM transmitters are more difficult for the consumer to install, which is never a good thing for helping sales.

But a recall? Is that truly realistic? Or is it just to help push the NAB's political agenda forward?

So lets take some of that Howard money and pay off the right people at the fcc. That's how buisiness is

Why doesn't the FCC tell the NAB to shut the fuck up and stop whining? They are losing listeners plain and simple, they know they are running out of time because FM sucks, and they want to cry foul.

FCC, would you please tell the NAB to shut up. I am so sick and tired of hearing their freaking crying. I would love to meet the freaking crying asshole president of the NAB so I could punch him in the freaking face. God, I get sick of hearing their garbage.

What crybabies. Are they going to insist on a recall of the millions of FM modulators for iPods as well?

Waah waah.

They've already succeeded. The new radio's FM mods suck. I bought one for my brother to turn him on to sat radio service. While he loved it and would have kept it the FM mod is to weak to provide a reliable signal, he has no tape deck in his car or iPod jack so he's cancelling. I'm sure he's not the only one. Whether it's to many wires in the car or just poor FM mod, these radios are becoming less user-friendly to the point where even seasoned listeners are getting sick of it. If they were to turn off my radios with strong FM mods thru a recall, as much as I love the servic,e I think I'd probably be done with it too. The NAB are creating a poor user experience which drives away customers and they're doing a good job of it.

How can they possibly force us to return our sat radios? I have one of the older starmate replays before they reconfigured the FM modulators. Personally I love the stronger modulator since it works practically all over my house. Screw the NAB. They're not getting their hands on my radio for anything.

WAHWAHPenus wants NAB to lick his hairy sweaty ballsack while he rapes their children in the mouth.

Both my XM radios have kickass FM mods. If only I could find away to jam the rest of the FM band while the XM radios are in operation

Post a comment

(or continue the conversation in the Orbitcast Forums)

Recent Entries

From the Forums...
Search Orbitcast:

Recent Readers
Latest Poll
Technology & Media Blogs
These are blogs that relate to technology, media or other specific industries, but not soley on satrad.
Sponsored Links

Copyright © 2008 Orbitcast Media, LLC.