Polk I-Sonic: Hands-On First Impressions
Remember the Polk I-Sonic? It's that all-in-one home audio entertainment system that throws AM/FM/CD/DVD/HD Radio and XM Satellite Radio into a blender and mixes it all together.
Well Orbitcast's review unit just arrived and here's some initial hands-on impressions on the unit.

First the HD Radio feature. I'll be honest in that I've never spent any money on buying an HD Radio unit (why would I?) so the opportunity to compare it to satellite radio was irresistible. Sure I've played with display/demo units, but that's hardly a good testing environment. The best environment is in your home with the volume cranked up.
Honestly (and I'm trying not to show any bias here) while the HD Radio stations that I could pick up sounded good, they didn't sound much better than regular FM. "CD-quality" is hardly a good description, and with the incredible quality of the speakers on this unit - trust me, you can tell the difference. But maybe I'll save my additional criticism of HD Radio for later, as this is just an initial impression of the Polk unit.
An option for the Polk Audio I-Sonic is the XM Mini-Tuner plus XM Antenna (sold separately). While this is an option, Polk has built-in XM into many of the unit functions, including the remote seen below.
The XM Mini-Tuner, which I've only seen with the Samsung Nexus previously, includes the Mini-Tuner cartridge as well as the dock and a separate XM antenna.
The Polk I-Sonic is more than just a radio. Much more. Just look at the back of the unit and you realize that video plays a key part in the overall experience.
Here's where the XM Mini-Tuner connects into the Polk I-Sonic:

The addition of the XM Mini-Tuner doesn't take up much room at all:
And with the push of a button you're surrounded with incredibly crisp XM channels.
A full review of the Polk Audio I-Sonic will be soon to come, but from the initial impressions this thing is a mind-blower. The speakers alone have an incredible range (goosebump factor of 10). I haven't yet touched the video capabilities, but it's audio capabilities alone will get an audiophile excited.
Pros:
- Incredible sound.
- Integrated everything.
- Easy XM installation/setup.
Cons:
- Price won't appeal to majority.
- HD Radio disappoints.
- Wish there was XMHD capabilties.



Comments
I still have my 1981 top-of-the-line Polk RTA 12s (I replaced the tweeters in 1991 - got'em direct from Polk). I can wait to hear this unit. Now that Polk has been purchased by Directed, I wonder if the next gen will be a Sirius unit.
Posted by: iband | October 10, 2006 5:14 PM
Nice Hands-On! You would think Polk would of done XMHD for even more superior sound quality but I guess regular XM sounded great all alone.
Posted by: ahigee ? | October 10, 2006 6:09 PM
Any idea what the story is with the (what looks to be a) covered-up USB 'B' connector there on the back, next to where the mini-tuner connects?
Posted by: TVGenius ? | October 10, 2006 6:25 PM
Notice the fcc statement...third photo from bottem. The fcc can't complain about this one. (HOPEFULLY)
Posted by: Craskill ? | October 10, 2006 8:52 PM
Wouldn't it be nice (and more convenient) if the XM Passport just went into a slot directly in the unit ? That would be a lot neater.
Posted by: cable guy | October 10, 2006 9:15 PM
Uhhhhhh, If I look carefully at the pics of the back of the unit, am I seeing that there are NO Optical Digital outputs???
Really?!
Forget it. The digital optical output is one of the compelling features of my Polk XRt12. Despite the XRt12's OLD chipset, the sound quality is just A-Mazing with the digital output. My XRt12... I think I'll keep her
Posted by: Mark Slocum | October 10, 2006 10:46 PM
I don't think that's USB. That looks like it could also be a tos-link fiber connection?
Posted by: Sean C | October 11, 2006 1:37 AM
That covered port could be a service jack for the HD Radio tuner. The HD Radio standard was designed from the start to be upgradeable as new features or improved codecs are developed, so many of the more recent tuners have a jack designed for updating the firmware.
Posted by: Anonymous Coward | October 11, 2006 8:13 AM
Enjoyed critique of the sound /speaker quality, but I think you didn't give HD radio a fair shake. Around here it is crystal clear and far superior to XM. (XM fades because of the area's large trees). Boston Acoustic's Receptor HD really sucks here, but the Accurian does OK reception-wise, but leave a lot to be desired fidelity-wise. I'd love to try the Polk here (Seattle area). Would it enable me to put away my RT 1000s?
Posted by: Ed | March 9, 2007 9:44 PM