XM2go vs XM2go (or, Inno vs AirWare)

Tuesday, May 9, 2006 at 6:36 PM
Tags: 2, XM

Ever since I wrote up the initial Pioneer Inno review where I talked about how superior the Inno's antenna is to the previous XM2go antenna, people have always wanted to see actual proof of this. Well, here you go.

Below are photos from both the Pioneer Inno and Pioneer AirWare - both in diagnostic mode - so you can see actual numbers of how the Inno performs in various conditions.

One thing to point out that's not evident from these shots is how quickly the Inno registers signal strength. When compared against the 1G XM2go, this refresh rate is much faster, with every slight movement quickly showing what your signal is.

A quick note about what these values are. The numbers to pay attention to are the BER % and the SAT C/N. BER stands for Bit Error Rate - the lower the number, the better the signal. SAT C/N stands for Carrier/Noise - essentially a signal-to-noise ratio - above 7 is good. 

This first shot is from INSIDE my office building in New York City. I only get terrestrial signal here, and a weak one at that. With the Inno, I can actually listen indoors to a degree, where the AirWare simply wouldn't pick up anything long enough to make listening bearable.

Pioneer Inno vs Pioneer AirWare
I know it's blurry, so here's what they read:

Inno
Terrestrial BER % - 1.5
SAT 1 C/N - 3.0
SAT 2 C/N - 3.0

AirWare
Terrestrial BER % - 6.4
SAT 1 C/N - 2.75
SAT 2 C/N - 3.0

Not only do I work in NYC, but I live in the middle of woods in Connecticut, a perfect test spot to show satellite signal (with no terrestrial repeaters anywhere). Check out the full North/South/East/West comparison after the jump...

 

Facing South, here's the Inno:
Pioneer Inno
Inno
SAT 1 BER % - 0.00
SAT 2 BER % - 8.1
Terr BER % - 100
SAT 1 C/N - 10.25
SAT 2 C/N - 3.75

AirWare facing South:
Pioneer AirWare
AirWare
SAT 1 BER % - 100
SAT 2 BER % - 9.1
Terr BER % - 100
SAT 1 C/N - 8.25
SAT 2 C/N - 8.50 

 

Now for the Inno facing North:
Pionner Inno
Inno
SAT 1 BER % - 0.1
SAT 2 BER % - 100
Terr BER % - 100
SAT 1 C/N - 12.75
SAT 2 C/N - 3.00

 

AirWare facing North:
Pionner AirWare
AirWare
SAT 1 BER % - 100
SAT 2 BER % - 29.3
Terr BER % - 100
SAT 1 C/N - 10.50
SAT 2 C/N - 5.00 

 

Inno facing East:
Pioneer Inno
Inno
SAT 1 BER % - 0.1
SAT 2 BER % - 100
Terr BER % - 100
SAT 1 C/N - 12.0
SAT 2 C/N - 3.25 

AirWare facing East:
Pioneer AirWare
AirWare
SAT 1 BER % - 49.2
SAT 2 BER % - 100
Terr BER % - 100
SAT 1 C/N - 10.00
SAT 2 C/N - 4.00 

 

And finally, the Inno facing West:
Pioneer Inno
Inno
SAT 1 BER % - 0.9
SAT 2 BER % - 6.4
Terr BER % - 100
SAT 1 C/N - 12.00
SAT 2 C/N - 5.25 

And the AirWare facing West as well:
Pioneer AirWare
AirWare
SAT 1 BER % - 17.0
SAT 2 BER % - 100
Terr BER % - 100
SAT 1 C/N - 5.75
SAT 2 C/N - 3.00

Just to give you an idea of the surroundings, this is seriously in the middle of the woods, so there are many trees overhead. I figured it was a nice worst case scenario for satellite reception. 

Questions? Feel free to fire away. 

TrackBack/Ping:

Post a comment

(or continue the conversation in the Orbitcast Forums)


Recent Entries

From the Forums...
Search Orbitcast:

Recent Readers
Latest Poll
Technology & Media Blogs
These are blogs that relate to technology, media or other specific industries, but not soley on satrad.
Sponsored Links





Copyright © 2008 Orbitcast Media, LLC.